English
434 Homework #10
You are of course free to utilize information obtained from web
sites
in your research project. You have already surfed some of the sites
linked
to the course homepage, but for this assignment I would like you to
search
for additional sites relevant to your topic.
Select a site that looks potentially useful for you and evaluate it.
(If you can’t locate one, you may use one of the ones linked to the
course
homepage.) Evaluating web sites can be tricky. Whereas print sources
generally
cannot be published without passing through a fairly extensive process
of expert evaluation and review that guarantees a basic level of
reliability,
material on the WWW often lacks that guarantee. But that in turn means
taking the trouble to assess a site is especially important.
Some questions to consider in evaluating a site:
- What
type of a site
is it, and who maintains or sponsors it (a company? a university? a
scholarly
organization? an advocacy group? a government agency? a non-profit
organization? a news organization? an information service? an
individual?)? What
do you know about the reputation or credentials of the individuals and
institutions involved? (Many sites include information about the
history and
mission of the sponsor.) How scholarly is the site?
-
Have you arrived at the site by following a link from another site you
have reason to regard as reputable and reliable?
-
When was the site last updated? Is it updated regularly? Do links to
other
sites work?
- Based
on what you know of the topic, does the information on the site seem to
be
comprehensive, accurate, and up-to-date? Does the site contain
references or a
bibliography, and if so, are these comprehensive and up-to-date?
- Is
the text on the site well-written, free of
grammar and spelling errors?
-
Has the site received awards? If so, for what and from whom?
Submit by class on March 8 in hard copy form an evaluation of the web
site you have selected. First list the site in proper MLA format (see section
5.9 in
the MLA Handbook), then
state whether you believe the site is reliable and explain why.